In the Lensli Academy we regularly inform you about practical situations that we encounter in the sector, we talk about insights gained in practice, we give you cultivation tips and we share our knowledge about other interesting substrate-related matters.

Academy – Pesticides in potting soil and substrate

Pesticides are hazardous substances that combat pests, usually to protect crops. After use of pesticides, residues can sometimes remain in the environment for a long time. Can pesticide residues also occur in potting soil or substrates and what are the risks then?

RHP has written an extensive factsheet about this, and we are happy to include this article in our own knowledge base. (Source: RHP)

“The EU has strict regulations for the approval of pesticides, which include an in-depth assessment of the safety and effects of these substances on human health and the environment. In the Netherlands, the 'Board for the Authorisation of Plant Protection Products and Biocides' (Ctgb) does this at a national level.”

Pesticides
Pesticides are chemical or biological substances that are used in various sectors and sometimes also at home to control pests. In agriculture and horticulture, pesticides are used to protect crops.

There are insecticides (against insects), herbicides (against weeds), fungicides (against fungi) and biocides (against various micro-organisms). Although these products are useful, they can also entail risks for the environment, humans and animals. This depends on the type of crop, the toxicity of the agent used, the concentration still present and the degree of (direct) exposure to it.

To minimize harmful effects, most countries have regulations in place. Certain hazardous pesticides have been banned for some time now. Sometimes residues of very slow-degrading pesticides can remain in the environment for a long time and be detectable.

Pesticides in substrate?
Pesticide residues can occur in potting soil and substrates if they are produced with renewable or circular raw materials that contain residue. Substrate raw materials often have a history from another chain. In that chain, pesticides (that were then still permitted) may have been used in the past.

The substrate raw material peat is free of residue, because no other activities have taken place in peat areas before. Most other raw materials do come from a chain with a history of possible pesticide use. For example, in the environment where the raw material originates or during a (previous) production process. A number of examples with a history are substrate raw materials such as compost, wood fibre and tree bark. GFT compost consists entirely of composted vegetable, fruit and garden waste. If pesticides have been used during gardening, this also ends up in the GFT waste and therefore in the compost. Wood fibre and tree bark are residual products from the wood industry, where pesticides can also be used. With the transition to increasing use of renewable raw materials, there is also a greater chance of pesticide residue in potting soil and substrates. Pesticide residues only partly disappear from the raw material through processing such as composting.

What are the guidelines of the RHP quality mark?
All quality requirements of the RHP quality mark are described in the RHP product certification scheme, which is continuously updated based on developments. There are no requirements for residues yet. As standard, RHP scans raw materials for residues of 1056 agents. Renewable raw materials regularly contain (low concentrations of) pesticide residues. In the period up to July 2023, residue(s) were found in the following RHP-certified raw materials:

Retail sometimes demands that potting soil and substrates are (practically) completely free of residues, but that is not realistic. In addition, measuring techniques are constantly improving, so that residues can also be demonstrated in very low concentrations.

In order to gain more insight into the extent to which residues are absorbed by plants, RHP started a research project in 2022. For this purpose, raw materials are used in which residue has been found. These products are processed in a substrate on which plants are grown, which are also tested for residues themselves. Any absorption by the plant will partly depend on the type of agent and the concentrations (which are often low). The research project will run until the end of 2024, after which RHP, together with external bodies, wants to develop requirements for residues in raw materials. Any values ​​found in the plants can be tested against the existing maximum residue limits (MRL). MRL indicates how much residue of the active substances of pesticides may remain in vegetables, for example, without endangering health. These are officially established values ​​that apply to Europe. MRL values ​​cannot be adopted one-on-one for substrates, but MRL values ​​are a useful tool for determining the requirements for substrates based on plant uptake. Incidentally, RHP has been carrying out risk assessments at suppliers of substrate raw materials for years. Think of on-site inspections at sawmills and coconut fibre factories. Risks in the chain, such as the chance of residue, are reduced for RHP-certified raw materials.

Advice for the user
If there are pesticide residues in potting soil or substrate, the question is of course whether there is a risk to the plant and humans. This is not yet fully known. The RHP study, which will run until the end of 2024, will provide more clarity about the inheritance of residues in
the plant and what consequences it has.

  • RHP certified raw materials are regularly scanned for
    residues of 1056 chemicals
  • RHP research should provide more clarity about plant uptake and possible health risks
  • RHP aims to establish acceptable residue levels and requirements for potting soil and substrate

Do you have questions or would you like to know more about this subject? Please contact your Lensli account manager or our Substrates Technical Product Manager Nick Vollmer by email n.vollmer@lensli.com or telephone +31 (6) 51269415.

We are happy to talk to you.

Source: Stichting RHP. You can download the article through this link.